Why We Love Beauty and the Beast Retellings

I loved Beauty and the Beast as a child. My sister had The Little Mermaid on VHS. I had Beauty and the Beast.

And I think part of the reason we keep coming back to the story is that there's something universal about the fantasy at its heart: falling in love with the person beneath the monster.

In the Disney version, once you get past the fairly significant problem of the Beast imprisoning Belle, he's really just a little rough around the edges. He has no manners. He has a temper. He looks frightening. But underneath all of that, he's actually a good person.

Belle discovers that the monster everyone can see isn't the real man underneath.

The film itself plays with that distinction. By the end, the frightening creature in the castle isn't necessarily the person we should be afraid of.

That's also where some modern retellings lose me.

There's a big difference between a character who looks monstrous and a character who actually behaves monstrously. Whether I want Beauty and the Beast to end up together really depends on the story. Why is she trapped with him in the first place? Who is responsible for her being there? How does he treat her once she is? What does he actually do to earn her trust?

Those questions can have completely different answers depending on the retelling, and perhaps that's another reason Beauty and the Beast has endured so well.

You can do almost anything with it.

It can take place in a traditional fantasy world or the modern day. It can be cozy, romantic, dark or genuinely horrifying. The Beast can be cursed, misunderstood, dangerous or actually monstrous. Beauty can save him, escape him, defeat him or decide he doesn't need saving at all.

At this point, I suspect almost every possible version has been explored somewhere.

And perhaps that's why Beauty and the Beast is so endlessly retellable. The castle, the curse and even the romance can change. The question at the centre remains the same:

Who is the real monster?

Previous
Previous

Would you want to read a prequel to What Falls to Us?

Next
Next

Would Lancaster Castle Actually Survive a Zombie Apocalypse?